Situation ethics, also called situational ethics, in ethics and theology, the position that moral decision making is contextual or dependent on a set of circumstances. Antinomianism says no guidelines or principles, not even love, can tell us whether an action is right or wrong. One example fletcher gives is of a married woman in a prison camp who has an affair and gets pregnant in order to get home to her family. Joseph fletcher 19051991 an american priest, a moral philosopher and a bioethicist, he wrote the book entitled the new morality 1966 and his moral responsibility.
Fletcher ascribes six fundamental principles to situation ethics. Situation ethics also rejects any attempt to turn these generalizations into firm and steadfast rules and laws, what fletcher 1966 called a form of ethical idolatry. Situation ethics holds that moral judgments must be made within the context of the entirety of a situation and that all normative features of a situation must be viewed as a. The teachings of jesus, says robinson, are not to be understood legalistically, as prescribing what christians must do whatever the. The new morality 1966 arose from his objections to both moral absolutism the view that there are fixed universal moral principles that have binding authority in all circumstances and moral relativism the view that there are no fixed moral principles at all. Proposing an ethic of loving concern, fletcher suggests that certain actssuch as lying, premarital sex, adultery, or even murdermight be. The new morality joseph fletcher 19051991 develops what he calls an ethical nonsystem. Three lessons which cover the theory of situation ethics with particular reference to fletcher as the new spec demands. Situation ethics in the light of vatican ii others always wrong, for all men, everywhere is a distortion of his teaching. Situational ethics it was developed by joseph fletcher. In this section we look into joseph fletcher s world of love, propositions and presuppositions. This is the same evil plan rehashed from the garden of eden.
An evaluation of joseph fletchers ethical formulations and defense of situation ethics. Advantages and disadvantages of situational ethics philosophy. Fletcher could be influenced by the ideas of bonhoeffer, barth. Episode 12, joseph fletchers situation ethics part i.
Situation ethics was developed during the late 1960s and 1970s, a time of great. Situation ethics explained by peter baron from peped youtube. Situation ethics was most famously championed by joseph fletcher 19051991 he believed that we should follow the rules until we need to break them for reasons of love. As a personal quest to understand the field of ethics better, i picked up the book situation ethics by joseph fletcher at a local college library.
Why did pope pius xii oppose situation ethics in 1952. Igniting a firestorm of controversy upon its publication in 1966, joseph fletchers situation ethics was hailed by many as a muchneeded reformation of. Situation ethics introduction in the introduction to the situation ethics. It is a relative what is right and wrong changes based on the situation and teleological what is right or. It is based on agape love christian unconditional love, and says that we should always do the most loving thing in any situation. People like to wallow or cower in the security of the law. In its new paperback form, this book is certain of continued attention in the current discussion of ethical problems. The thesis that robinson and fletcher have nailed up in the market place is that christian ethics is a radical ethic of the situation with nothing prescribedexcept love. Propositions of situation ethics fletcher summarizes the fundamentals of situation ethics in a series of six propositions. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools.
The new moralityjoseph fletcher 1905 1991 develops what he calls an ethical nonsystem. Fletcher rejects both the legalistic and antinomian approaches and opts instead for situation ethics. It is a relative what is right and wrong changes based on the situation and teleological what is right or wrong is based on the consequences or end goal theory. Situation ethics does well to take into account at least theoretically the importance of motives, means, ends, and results in moral decisions fletcher 1966, 142, but fletcher s. Fletcher would say that here is a situation where we ought not to follow the principle do not murder but rather do the most loving thing, which in this case turns out to be murder. This paper will argue that inflexible ethical absolutism is too restrictive to proffer solutions in significant areas of conflict and that joseph fletchers situation ethics. Situation ethics is a 20th century christian approach to ethics devised by joseph fletcher. His other book on this theme is moral responsibility situation ethics at work 25s.
An appraisal of situation ethics honest morality,tap lambert academic publishing. This book reminds me of a line, if you will forgive the crossing of genres, in the popular harry potter series. Love is the only thing that is intrinsically good 2. Since then, almost every publication on situational ethics has referred to the model presented in fletcher s writings. Give 1 of fletchers examples of situation ethics and explain the point of it 3. Publication date 1966 topics christian ethics, situation ethics, morale, situatieethiek publisher philadelphia, westminster press collection inlibrary. Moral responsibility situation ethics at work fletcher, joseph on. Situation ethics the new morality download ebook pdf. Situational ethics is a code word indicating i alone am god and i alone can and will make my own decisions as i alone see fit without the influence of the traditional god. According to him, moral decisions cannot be made on the basis. Joseph fletcher wrote about situation ethics after jat robinson, in his book. Weve got the questions, and for once, weve got the answers.
Fletcher, who became prominently associated with this approach in the englishspeaking world due to his book situation ethics, stated that all laws and rules and principles and ideals and norms, are only contingent, only valid if they happen to serve love in the particular situation. Pg 158159 looking at this book from a fiftyyearslater viewpoint, one is perhaps most surprised to see how christianly fletchers approach originally wasparticularly in light of his later secularist and atheistic approach. The relevance of joseph fletchers situation ethics for animal. Mar 20, 2014 joseph fletcher 19051991joseph fletcher 19051991 he was an american professor whohe was an american professor who founded the theory of situation ethics infounded the theory of situation ethics in the 1960s. Situation ethics homosexuality fletcher homosexuality is. Give 1 of fletcher s examples of situation ethics and explain the point of it 3. Click download or read online button to get situation ethics the new morality book now. A explain how fletchers fundamental principles can be applied to polyamory 20 situation ethics is a 20th century christian approach to ethics devised by joseph fletcher. The author endeavors to show how disregard for divine law, though seemingly attractive, reasonable, and practical, is untenable.
A explain how fletchers fundamental principles can be. Situation ethics attempts to answer questions like these by affirming that doing the loving thing is a higher priority than obedience to gods law. New as ethics aqa spec fletcher and situation ethics. His book caused a fire storm amongst the public because it legitimised the general postwar dissatisfaction with authority. Some textbooks claim that there is therefore an absolute principle in situation ethics to always. Study 15 terms situation ethics quotes flashcards quizlet. This book seems to be the definitive guide on the matter of situation ethics as it began to infiltrate religious circles.
Proposing an ethic of loving concern, fletcher suggests that certain actssuch as lying, premarital sex, adultery, or even murdermight be morally right, depending on the circumstances. Fletcher was an episcopalian priest, so this theory may be described as a christian ethic a form of christian relativism, or liberal christian morality. Situation ethics was developed by american anglican theologian joseph f. In using the word good, situationism holds that something is good because god wills it so nothing in and for.
Welcome to episode 12 part i of ii on joseph fletcher s situation ethics. As a scripture for the openendedness of situation ethics turn to romans 14. It mustnt be confused with cultural relativism, which says that there is no objective morality, and moral values vary from one society to another. Nov 07, 2015 give 3 reasons why situation ethics could be seen as a christian ethic 2. Joseph fletcher was professor of social ethics at the episcopal theological school, cambridge, mass. Situation ethics, the position that moral decision making is contextual or dependent on a set of circumstances.
Jesus said man was not made for the sabbath, suggesting that rules are there for the benefit of people, so fletcher. Decision making should base on circumstances of a particular situation, and fixed law should never include in it. Supplementary materials or chapters on these topics must be added for this introduction to be better suited for an ethics class. For joseph fletcher, ethical standard is situation ethics. Joseph francis fletcher april 10, 1905 in newark, new jersey october 28, 1991 in charlottesville, virginia was an american professor who founded the theory of situational ethics in the 1960s, and was a pioneer in the field of bioethics. He was a pioneer in bioethics and washe was a pioneer in bioethics and was involved in the areas of abortion,involved in.
Brilliant, snape once again youve put your keen and. Situation ethics the new morality download ebook pdf, epub. Fletcher was an episcopal priest, a member of the euthanasia educational counsel, and. You can find the main text we will be discussing at the bottom of the page. There are tasks for students to complete throughout, though it is expected that students will take notes as well. An introduction to theories of right and wrong, 2nd ed. Pdf situation ethics download full pdf book download. His book situation ethics is used as a model for the situation ethics platform and nearly all later studies and research refer to fletcher s model. Situation ethics introduction joseph fletcher is identified as the father of situation ethics as well as the pioneer of biomedical ethics. Part i covers utilitarianism, kants ethics, aristotelian virtue ethics, natural law theory, and joseph fletchers situation ethics. Fletcher s situation ethics centers on the idea of love. Bibliographical footnotes accessrestricteditem true. Joseph fletchers situation ethics free download as pdf file.
Literally, it is a system of ethics that evaluates acts in light of their situational context rather than by the application of moral absolutes besides that. Fletcher also lays down four working principals of situation ethics, which can be seen as the justification for situation ethics. Fletcher was a leading academic proponent of the potential benefits of abortion, infanticide, euthanasia. The book reveals how a situationalist follows a misguided ego rather than an objective standard. Situation ethics holds that moral judgments must be made within the context of the entirety of a situation and that all normative features of a situation must be viewed as a whole. His book caused a fire storm amongst the public because. Situation ethics is the most promising road to a moral community. Situation ethics homosexuality fletcher homosexuality is historically and conventionally related to criminal law civil partnership act 2004 amended sex discrimintaion act 2008 meant that people could be charged if they discriminated against homosexuals, fletcher, six fundamental principles, strengths, polyamory. Situation ethics was a term joseph fletcher 19051991 adopted in 1966. For fletcher, the ultimate norm of christian ethics is love. There are no universal moral rules or rights each case is unique and deserves a unique solution. Pdf situational ethics mike nathanael l manalo academia. Apr 07, 2011 situation ethics was a term joseph fletcher 19051991 adopted in 1966. The methodology of situation ethics seems to be misrepresented by fletcher.
His work, situation ethics, founded the modern situational ethics movement. Joseph fletchers situation ethics ten commandments love. Igniting a firestorm of controversy upon its publication in 1966, joseph fletcher s situation ethics was hailed by many as a muchneeded reformation of moralityand as an invitation to anarchy by others. You know better than god does so you do as you please. Fletcher is thoroughly informed on the epistemological, ontological and ethical topics that he covers in situation ethics. Situational ethics was pioneered by joseph fletcher 19051991. Give 3 reasons why situation ethics could be seen as a christian ethic 2.
1039 409 127 993 645 657 1151 513 931 1030 1311 646 659 1100 62 810 515 493 306 122 1006 790 607 584 300 640 99 688 1175 1413 982 1199 570 1250 275 1285 1039 1454 118 1495 1458 912 1295 1187 1057 1168 28 192 695 1457